Thomas Breda

PSE Professor

  • Senior Researcher
  • Co-Head of the Labour and Employment Division
  • CNRS
  • Institut des politiques publiques
  • Member of the Institute of Public Policies
Research groups
  • Associate researcher at the Education Policy and Social Mobility Chair.
Research themes
  • Education
  • Labour Markets
  • Public policy
  • Social protection
  • Work organization and employment relations
Contact

Address :48 Boulevard Jourdan,
75014 Paris, France

Publications HAL

  • L’index de l’égalité professionnelle offre-t-il un panorama fidèle des écarts de rémunération entre les femmes et les hommes ? Journal article

    In September 2018, the French government implemented a suite of measures to reduce wage gaps between women and men. Among these measures, a requirement on all private companies with more than 50 employees to calculate their professional equality index. They must attain a minimum thresholdon this index, or face sanctions. We analyse the efficacy of this index in highlighting pay inequality between women and men. After first explaining the rules for calculating the index, we analyse the results for companies in 2020 and compare them with male-female pay inequalities measured using other indicators. We observe that the pay gap indicator as measured by the index tends to minimise the true level of inequality, resulting from the exclusion of certain employees, from the option for companies to declare the index to be incalculable, and the methodologies chosen.

    Journal: La Revue de l'IRES

    Published in

  • The Double-Edged Sword of Role Models: A Systematic Narrative Review of the Unintended Effects of Role Model Interventions on Support for the Status Quo Journal article

    <div><p>Role model interventions are often designed to foster students’ pursuit of specific careers and are commonly employed in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM).</p><p>Here, we drew on social-psychological theories of intergroup relations to hypothesize that role model interventions might also unintentionally shape students’ beliefs and preferences concerning the broader social system-their ideologies. Specifically, role model interventions may lead students to view the (inequitable) status quo in STEM as natural and acceptable. A systematic narrative review (35 articles, 42 studies) examined these hypothesized side effects. This review indicated that the ideological side effects of role model interventions were rarely considered in the literature on role models. Although limited, the few relevant findings revealed both undesirable side effects of role model interventions on students’ ideologies (e.g., greater endorsement of the status quo) and effects that are-from our perspectivedesirable (e.g., greater awareness of gender bias in STEM). This review demonstrates that role models can be a double-edged sword and serves as a call to evaluate role model interventions based on criteria beyond motivation.</p></div>

    Journal: Review of Research in Education

    Published in

  • Does Feasibility Explain the Unequal Development of Working From Home? Pre-print, Working paper

    Using rich historical surveys on job tasks and advanced machine learning techniques, we study which jobs can be moved from the office to home over three decades in France.<p>The share of jobs that can be done from home has increased steadily from 14% in 1991 to 45% in 2021. At the same time, actual Working From Home (WFH) remained limited to less than one fifth of its full potential before the Covid-19 crisis and is still below it in 2021.</p><p>The growth of WFH is largely unrelated to the evolution of job tasks, implying that the main obstacles to WFH have not been technical constraints. Low-skilled employees in particular have jobs that have long been largely teleworkable but they were barely teleworking before the Covid-19 crisis and remained still below 50% of their full potential during it. This pattern is not explained by differences in workers’ desire to telework. It implies that the well-known large inequality in access to WFH along the earnings distribution cannot be attributed only to feasibility constraints and is potentially inefficient.</p>

    Published in

  • Early Gendered Performance Gaps in Math: An Investigation on French Data Pre-print, Working paper

    While there is no gap in math performance at the beginning of Grade 1, a gap in favor of boys appears and widens during the first year of primary school. Using standardized national assessments administered during Grade 1 (CP) to more than 2.5 million pupils in France between 2018 and 2022, we show that this relative drop in girls’ performance is observed for all the cohorts and most of the exercises assessed. The greatest drop-off occurs among the best-performing girls at the start of Grade 1 (those in the top 1 % initially). These girls lose an average of nearly 7 percentile ranks at the start of second grade compared with boys in the same initial percentile. The emergence of a gender gap in math performance during Grade 1 is observed across all social categories and family compositions, and throughout the country. Girls lose slightly less ground compared to boys in classes where the top student in math is a girl, and in priority networks public schools (REP or REP+). However, characteristics of the school environment explain only a small part of the overall dynamics, suggesting that girls are losing ground compared to boys in every strata of society.

    Published in