Capital vs. Labour: the Effect of Income Sources on Attitudes Toward the Top 1 Percent

Pre-print, Working paper: We examine the impact of providing information on the income of the top 1% earners on attitudes towards this group. We focus on the income at the top derived from capital and labour, an aspect scarcely studied in previous literature. We carried out a randomized online survey with 2000 French respondents. Our findings reveal that: (i) at the baseline, respondents tend to overestimate the income of the top 1%, have no clear priors on their capital vs. labor shares, and want them to pay a higher income tax rate than the current one; (ii) providing quantitative information about the income sources at the top consistently shifts attitudes toward the rich to the unfavorable spectrum. This shift does not result from experimenter demand effects; (iii) individuals most responsive to our treatments vote for left-wing candidates and have egalitarian notions of justice.

Author(s)

Oscar Barrera-Rodriguez, Emmanuel Chávez

Date of publication
  • 2023
Keywords JEL
H20 H24 P16
Keywords
  • Top 1 percent
  • Income tax
  • Capital income shares
Internal reference
  • World Inequality Lab Working Papers n°2023-19
Version
  • 1